Robert Bork, Jr. on DA Alvin Bragg’s Antitrust Overreach
By Paul Steidler: Comedian and actor Jimmy Durante once famously said, “Everybody wants to get into the act!” And with Manhattan District Attorney (DA) Alvin Bragg announcing a new “Corporate Crime and Antitrust Task Force” on October 14, it is clear he wants in on this high-profile realm of law enforcement, which, until recently, had been generally reserved to the federal government.
To be sure, states are taking more widespread and even audacious actions on proposed mergers and antitrust enforcement. Ashley Baker of the Committee for Justice, spoke about this at our July 24 Capitol Hill Tech Conference.
In an October 20 in-depth analysis of DA Bragg’s announcement and its ramifications, Robert Bork, Jr., discusses why the October 14 announcement is significant and why DA Bragg’s future actions merit close monitoring.
Mr. Bork does acknowledge that DA Bragg has the authority to investigate certain antitrust conduct, such as bid rigging for city contracts. There may also be local industries concentrated in Manhattan that DA Bragg is better suited to investigate than federal authorities. DA Bragg’s true focus, though, seems to be on changing public policy towards antitrust.
To be sure, as the elected DA for Manhattan, this is Bragg’s decision. It is notable, though, that he is championing many of the positions advocated by former Federal Trade Commission Chair Lina Khan, now a close adviser to New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
Key excerpts from Mr. Bork follow.
Ambitious and Disruptive Goals
“Bragg says his goal is ‘systemic accountability,’ and the announcement promises to ‘catalyze systemic reform.’ That is how a regulator talks about an industry he means to reshape, not how a prosecutor talks about crimes he means to punish…”
“A corporate structure is not a crime, and wanting to reform an industry is no substitute for proving that someone broke the law. Antitrust depends on keeping those two things apart.”
Inhibiting Business Innovation and Competition
“Officials who say they are defending competition may end up restricting it. Unpredictable enforcement gives businesses a reason to avoid aggressive but lawful competition moves. Large companies can absorb compliance and litigation costs that smaller rivals cannot. Intervention meant to curb corporate power can end up shielding established firms from new competitors.”
Intimidation as a Strategy
“A prosecutor doesn’t need to win in court to have influence. Subpoenas are expensive. Investigations hurt reputations, rattle investors, and run up legal bills. The threat of criminal charges pushes companies towards a deal, and many will accept limits on perfectly legal conduct to avoid years of litigation. A prosecutor who wants to change corporate behavior can get through a settlement what no court would order after a trial.”
DA Bragg’s Responsibility to the Public
“Alvin Bragg has every right to prosecute crimes in his jurisdiction. He has no commission to redesign American capitalism. Neither does Lina Khan, the mayor of New York, or any other official.”
To read Mr. Bork’s full analysis, click here.